She was released again in 2008 as a 25th Anniversary Edition pony and in 2018 as a 35th Anniversary Pony.
The name Butterscotch was used again in the G3 line. This version of Butterscotch had a yellow pearlescent body with yellow hair and her symbol was two brown and yellow lollipops tied with red bows. She was first released in a promotion pack as a free pony that came with Sparkleworks or Minty. She was later released with clothing in a set called "Berry Pickin' Fun with Butterscotch," with Easter accessories in a Target-exclusive release, and as one of three playset ponies with the Super Sundaes Ice Cream Parlor playset sold exclusively at CVS Pharmacy stores.